Pakistan Supreme Court Suspends Sentence, Lawyers Re-Arrested
Pakistan's Supreme Court suspended a 17-year sentence for human rights lawyers Imaan Mazari-Hazir and Hadi Ali Chattha on September 17.

The Supreme Court of Pakistan suspended a 17-year sentence and granted bail to human rights lawyers Imaan Mazari-Hazir and Hadi Ali Chattha on September 17. On that same day, Islamabad police re-arrested them inside Adiyala Jail before their release, detaining them on separate anti-terrorism charges. This sequence demonstrates the judiciary's apparent inability to enforce its own rulings against executive power.
Charges and trial context
Imaan Mazari-Hazir and Hadi Ali Chattha were convicted and sentenced on January 24, 2026, under the Prevention of Electronic Crimes Act for social media posts. Their posts criticized the military and supported Baloch and Pashtun activists. A separate trial under the Anti-Terrorism Act resulted in a 10-year prison sentence on October 29, 2026. This conviction related to an incident on October 25, 2024, during a Test match between England and Pakistan in Rawalpindi. The lawyers were accused of removing traffic barriers installed at Islamabad’s Zero Point as part of security arrangements for the visiting cricket team. The prosecution in this security breach case relied exclusively on police testimony, with no independent witnesses presented. The court acquitted them of ancillary charges including criminal intimidation and rioting. Judge Tahir Abbas Sipra, presiding at Adiala Jail in Rawalpindi, handed down the verdict. The court dismissed their defence that they were targeted for their human rights work, though it noted the act of removing a barrier appeared to be a very common, ordinary type of incident.
They have been in custody since January 23, 2024. Their bail applications for a protest case from March 2025 remain pending. A case concerning that protest was registered at Islamabad’s Kohsar police station. An Anti-Terrorism Act section was later added to that file, which formed the basis for their September re-arrest. They pleaded not guilty to all allegations, rejecting them entirely.
Systemic judicial concerns
Civil society, lawyers, and international organizations have raised alarms about the independence of Pakistan's judiciary. These concerns follow the twenty-sixth and twenty-seventh constitutional amendments, which are seen as undermining judicial autonomy. A year ago, two supreme court justices and one high court judge resigned in protest following the twenty-seventh amendment. Just yesterday, a judge of the Lahore high court resigned, citing executive interference in judicial functions. The lawyers' case exemplifies this climate. They have been consistently denied the right to an open and fair trial, including being barred from attending court in person and held behind a cage-like structure during hearings. On October 10, 2026, the Anti-Terrorism Court dismissed their petitions challenging the terrorism charges after they were not brought to court and participated only via video link from prison.
Human rights advocacy and international response
Imaan Mazari-Hazir is a human rights lawyer and woman human rights defender known for advocating for persecuted religious and ethnic communities and for criticizing Pakistan's military and security forces. Hadi Ali Chattha is a human rights lawyer who has represented victims of false blasphemy cases, sexual violence, rape, and enforced disappearances. Their work has drawn accusations of targeting security forces. Amnesty International states the convictions are an indictment of Pakistan's justice system. The organization's Senior Director for Regional Human Rights Impact, Yasmine Ahmed, said anti-terrorism charges are being used to punish human rights advocacy. Amnesty International urges the immediate release of the pair and the dropping of all charges. Front Line Defenders states the conviction is part of a sustained pattern of judicial harassment designed to keep the defenders detained despite the Supreme Court's release order. The group calls for immediate and unconditional release of the defenders and dismissal of all convictions and cases against them.





