Voice and Witness
Themes

New Zealand Parties Clash on Human Rights in Election Debate

Seven political parties debated civil and political rights, including the Treaty of Waitangi and economic inequality, highlighting stark divisions ahead of the New Zealand election.

Seven political parties debated civil and political rights, including the Treaty of Waitangi and economic inequality...

Seven political parties clashed over core human rights issues in a televised debate on Thursday. The discussion centered on Te Tiriti o Waitangi, economic inequality, and the future of te reo Māori, revealing deep political divides.

Party Positions

Shane Jones, the deputy leader of NZ First, defended his party's plan to abolish the Waitangi Tribunal. He argued the tribunal had completed its historical work. In contrast, Labour's Willie Jackson described the current coalition government as the most anti-Māori government of his lifetime. The Green Party wants to entrench the Māori version of the treaty in law, while Labour opposes that move. Act also seeks to shut down the tribunal after it hears the last historical claim.

The debate also turned to gangs. Te Pāti Māori co-leader Rawiri Waititi stated that gangs had been politically manufactured. He argued for addressing the social conditions that lead to gang formation.

On language rights, parties differed sharply. Te Pāti Māori advocates making te reo Māori education compulsory in schools. Rawiri Waititi said Māori should be prioritised for spaces in te reo classes. Shane Jones defended NZ First's policy to make English an official language. Act opposes making te reo compulsory.

Economic Solutions

The cost of living crisis dominated part of the debate. Parties proposed various economic solutions to address inequality.

Green Party co-leader Marama Davidson backed breaking up the supermarket duopoly to lower grocery prices. Act's Nicole McKee rejected the idea of a publicly-owned supermarket. Shane Jones said he had been willing to take on the supermarket giants in 2014 and stated that government does not generate jobs, but the private sector does. NZ First plans to expand mining to create well-paid jobs.

Rawiri Waititi pushed his party's plan to put more money into whānau pockets through tax changes and a food credit. The Greens proposed a significant $2.4 billion investment in marae. Davidson said decisions over how that money was distributed should sit with Māori rather than government. National's representative, Tama Potaka, pointed to funding already provided to marae.

Health and Representation

Health funding became a point of contention linked to ethnic equity. The coalition government has a directive to allocate health funding according to need rather than ethnicity. Two politicians at the debate stated they believe New Zealand's health system is racist. The Opportunity Party candidate, Eden Skipper, challenged others to support a 10-year plan to address systemic problems in healthcare.

Electoral consequences were also noted. The Tāmaki Makaurau seat is seen as consequential after Labour's Kerrin Leoni attended a Mongrel Mob fundraiser and subsequently resigned.

The future of the Waitangi Tribunal remains uncertain.

Related coverage

More from Themes